Playing love interests in a musical seems like the perfect start to a strong relationship.

Henningsen opened up toPeopleabout the start of their relationship and how they actually started dating.

Luckily, that month pretty much solidified for us that it was worth the risk."

Erika Henningsen and Kyle Selig smiling

But I didn’t know I’d meet my best friend.

[…] I have loved every second of being by your side.

ANNNNND jokes on all you guys, because I still get to see her everyday."

Kyle Selig and Erika Henningsen making a funny face

So we’re doing this, officially.

She said yes, btw, she’s not just keeping the ring."

She penned a sweetcaptionto him on his birthday in 2021.

Erika Henningsen smiling

“Happy birth date to this man.

In an Instagrampost, Henningsen shared her gratitude for everyone who helped them plan the day.

“Thank you Kyle Selig for convincing me to throw a party for the ages.

Because weddings aren’t just about the two people exchanging rings.

A Broadway showmance-turned-marriage for the ages, and we love to see it.