Dean Forester, played by Jared Padalecki, is Rory’s first and tallest love interest.

High-society Logan Huntzberger doesn’t enter the picture until much later.

Even Alexis Bledel (aka Rory) has a hard time deciding between Dean, Jess, and Logan.

Rory and Dean on bus

““I can’t single somebody out,” she said.

Fair enough we wouldn’t want to face the wrath of"Gilmore Girls"stans either.

As for that intimate scene that Dean and Rory share in Season 4?

Rory and Dean in bedroom

Bledel didn’t necessarily think it made sense for her character.

That wasn’t the only reason why it was difficult to film, however.

Fans were also upset by Rory’s decision, calling her the “villain” in the situation.

Jared Padalecki with microphone

Alexis Bledel’s moral qualms weren’t the only barrier to filming the intimate scene, however.

The bed yes, the bed presented an even greater challenge.

“My feet definitely were off it.

However, the breakout “Supernatural” star cringes when he remembers another moment.

Meanwhile, one of Padalecki’s favorite Stars Hollow scenes was short and simple.

“It was actually a scene withEd Herrmann,” he toldEntertainment Weeklyin another interview.

and I’m like “How tall are you?'”