Still, the Hallmark Channel managed to make the perfect choice when they gave the role to Erin Krakow.

In oneInstagram post, Krakow showed off her workout attire with a mirror selfie.

“This is 38!”

Chris McNally, Erin Krakow, and Kevin McGarry posing

He went on to say, “A little wiser, and my back hurts more!

Thank you all for the lovely and heartwarming messages!

So grateful for everything!”

Erin Krakow taking mirror selfie

Three “When Calls the Heart” hunks, of course!

And folks following Jack Wagner on Instagram got exactly that on August 6th.

Wagner, who plays Bill Avery, posteda piccaptioned “Sunday Hang” with a sunglasses emoji.

Kevin McGarry blowing out birthday candles

The photo shows three sunglasses-clad costars: Wagner and his pals, Kevin McGarry and Chris McNally.

In real life, though,McNally is half of another lovely couple with fellow Hallmark star Julie Gonzalo.

Krakow is in a relationship with costar Ben Rosenbaum, who plays Mike Hickam.

Jack Wagner, Kevin McGarry, and Chris McNally smiling in sunglasses

What Heartie wouldn’t want to be a fly on the wall at this double date?

“News just reached Italy,” Wallace captioned the adorable image.

She added, “Mamma Mia!

Chris McNally posing on the beach with his dogs

Here we go again!

#Season10 Congrats to my When Calls the Heart family #hearties.”

Still, thispictureshe shared on Instagram in November 2022 proves that the pregnant mama glow is all too real.

Kayla Wallace, Kevin McGarry, Ben Rosenbaum, and Erin Krakow smiling in Italy

If this timeline makes you wonder why Faith isn’t pregnant in Season 10, your math is correct.

Brooks' pregnancy didn’t throw a curveball into Faith’s story, thanks to some Hallmark magic.

I’m so excited for you to see all the hilarious ways we hid the bump this season."

Kavan Smith smiling in selfie

She added a thank you to the Hallmark Channel for their support.

Whether showing off the bump or hiding it, Brooks makes a truly beautiful mom.

And, hey who could blame him?

Pascale Hutton and Erin Krakow posing

She managed to prove us wrong, though, when she took to her Instagram account back in March.

Burnett posted a breathtakingheadshotproving she’s a true natural beauty.

Her hair and makeup are pared down with minimal products and an easy, laidback look.

Burnett is a true stunner, and we’re gonna need her to drop the skincare routine ASAP.

Kavan Smith’s smile lights up Paris

Attention, fans of the Coulters!

We’ve definitely never seen Leland wearing glasses or sporting a scruffy beard.

The snap shows the two leading ladies dressed to the nines and flashing stunning smiles.