Holmes wed immigration lawyer Marilee Fiebig in 2010, with whom she shares one daughter.
Robach also married in 2010, walking down the aisle with “Melrose Place” actor Andrew Shue.
This led to Robach and Holmes being suspended from ABC before they were ultimately fired.
There have been some conflicting reports regarding the state of the marriages at the time of the affair.
Allegedly, Fiebig and Shue grew close after bonding over their shared experience with the public breakups.
This seemingly brought them together for the best.
“It turned into something else, and they’re connected over their values.
It’s bigger than the affair now,” the source toldPage Six.
Andrew Shue and Amy Robach concluded their divorce months earlier, in March 2023.
